Back to 31 works

DEEP GUIDE · PRINT LOCATORS · FILM MATRIX

30

《缠绕的诗学:德勒兹思维方法研究》

秦兰珺 / Qin Lanjun

From the eight postulates of thought, true ideas, and genetic definition to expression, differentiation, Alice, and the evaluation of life

A method of thought is not a set of rules preceding its object. It is a constrained movement formed as concepts, texts, traditions, and interpreters enter one another. Entwinement does not mean that everything is connected; it tracks how a problem forces concepts across established levels and produces difference.

Simplified Chinese · 中国文联出版社 · 2017 · ISBN 9787519024956

UNITS
9
LOCATORS
68
CURATED BOOK CASES
0
EXTENSIONS
14
Atlas-original guide card for The Poetics of Intertwinement, with crossing paths representing concepts, texts, and interpretive methods entering one another
Atlas-original guide card · not the book coverVerify bibliography source
01

CENTRAL ARGUMENT

What this book actually advances

CONTRIBUTION

Rather than arranging Deleuze chronologically by book, Qin Lanjun reconstructs a methodological machine. She first clears the postulates of recognition and representation, then uses Spinozist true ideas, expression, and immanent cause to show how method validates itself within its object. Differentiation, event, sense, and the paradoxes of Alice become observable operations of thought, before creation is finally tested by its effects on the capacities of life.

PAGINATION

The verified copy is continuously numbered through p.404. PDF page = print page + 22, so print pp.1–404 correspond to PDF pp.23–426. The guide displays print pages only.

SCOPE

Nine reading units, 68 single- or adjacent-double-page locators, 18 concept groups, eight relation cards, fourteen site-extension films, five outward perspectives, and a five-step route. The source book analyses no titled feature film.

PUBLICATION BOUNDARY

Entwinement is not free association, becoming is not a change of costume, and a mirror does not by itself make a crystal. Every move into cinema must begin with a visible or audible relation and then show why the concept applies. All fourteen films are site extensions, not Qin Lanjun's filmography.

02

CHAPTER ARGUMENT CHAINS

9 reading units with exact print locators

00
pp. 1–12 · 导言

Turning entwinement from metaphor into research procedure

Methodological research must track how concepts work among text, tradition, and interpretation rather than substituting biography or period labels for argument.

The introduction gives entwinement three senses: thinkers and problems enter one another, levels within a text are nested, and the interpreter's operations enter the interpreted object. The book's three parts thus form an experiment moving from clearing postulates, through reconstructing interpretation, to application and evaluation.

pp. 1–5

Biography is only an entry

A twentieth-century life and twenty-first-century thought establish a historical position without explaining concepts through life events.

pp. 6–9

Three faces of entwinement

Intellectual lineage, textual relation, and interpretive act enter one another while remaining distinguishable.

pp. 10–12

Three parts as a methodological experiment

Clearing, interpretation, and application are not linear steps; each later operation returns to and revises the earlier one.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 1–2

    Deleuze's life, reception, and status as a twenty-first-century thinker frame the research problem.

  2. pp. 3–4

    Methodological research does not label a philosophy by period; it follows how concepts work.

  3. pp. 6–7

    The first layer of entwinement is the mutual entry of thinkers, problems, and concepts within interpretation.

  4. pp. 8–9

    The second and third layers concern nesting within the text and between interpreter and object.

  5. pp. 10–11

    The book moves from clearing postulates and reconstructing interpretation to application and reflection.

  6. p. 12

    Entwinement is a practical procedure of thought, not merely a metaphor for mixture.

01
pp. 17–77 · 第一章 思维的形象和八个预设

How eight postulates turn thought into a recognition machine

Thought is not recognition naturally initiated by a well-intentioned subject. It begins when a sign that existing categories cannot recognize forces each faculty beyond its ordinary use.

The chapter dismantles eight postulates—innate thought, common sense and good sense, recognition, representation, error, proposition, problem, and knowledge—before using learning and discord among the faculties to explain how thought actually occurs. Recognition retains an everyday function but loses its status as the model of creative thought.

pp. 17–20

Postulate one: innate thought

The subject is presumed to think naturally and move toward truth, concealing the conditions under which thought begins.

pp. 21–25

Postulate two: common sense and good sense

The faculties are presumed to agree upon the same object and move together from indetermination to determination.

pp. 26–31

Postulate three: recognition

Different sensations, memories, and imaginings are subordinated to the same object, leaving difference as mere aspects of identity.

pp. 32–45

Postulate four: representation

Identity, resemblance, analogy, and opposition arrange difference into forms governable by existing concepts.

pp. 46–52

Postulate five: error

Reducing failure of thought to false judgment misses deeper mechanisms such as stupidity, baseness, and false problems.

pp. 53–58

Postulate six: proposition

The truth of propositions cannot replace the truth of problems; deriving problems from ready answers reverses the order of thought.

pp. 59–64

Postulate seven: problem

A problem is not a blank waiting to be filled by an answer but a productive structure distributing the conditions of solutions.

pp. 65–69

Postulate eight: knowledge

Learning occurs through an encounter with signs and cannot be reduced to copying established knowledge.

pp. 70–77

Conclusion and objections

In encounter, faculties exceed ordinary use and become discordant; this compulsion rather than voluntary recognition initiates thought.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 17–18

    Innate thought treats everyone's natural capacity to think as an unexamined starting point.

  2. pp. 21–22

    Common sense and good sense pre-coordinate the faculties around the same object.

  3. pp. 26–27

    Recognition returns difference to the identifying loop of this is the same thing.

  4. pp. 32–33

    Representation arranges difference from conceptual identity, opening the fourth postulate.

  5. pp. 39–40

    Representation domesticates difference through identity, resemblance, analogy, and opposition.

  6. pp. 46–47

    Treating failure only as error hides deeper conditions such as stupidity, baseness, and false problems.

  7. pp. 53–54

    Truth or falsity of propositions is not that of problems; ready answers reverse the order of thought.

  8. pp. 59–60

    A problem is not a gap awaiting an answer but a productive structure distributing solution conditions.

  9. pp. 65–66

    Learning occurs in encounters with signs and cannot be reduced to copying knowledge outcomes.

  10. pp. 70–71

    Encounter pushes each faculty beyond ordinary use into discordant transcendent exercise.

  11. pp. 76–77

    Genuine thought is not voluntary recognition but compulsion by something unrecognizable.

02
pp. 78–93 · 第二章 真观念的规定方法:德勒兹对《知性改进论》的阐释

How a true idea produces method and object together

If a method requires another method as guarantee, it regresses infinitely. A true idea exhibits method within its own movement through reflective form and expressive content.

Through the Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect, the chapter recasts method from external rule into the productive relation of the idea itself. An idea can become an idea of the idea while expressing the cause of its object, so form, content, means, end, method, and object validate one another in one genetic chain.

pp. 78–83

Method and infinite regress

Method cannot wait forever for another set of rules to legitimate it; it must validate itself in the movement of thought.

pp. 84–88

Form of the true idea: reflection

The idea becomes an idea of the idea, making the formation of knowledge itself perceptible.

pp. 89–91

Content of the true idea: expression

A true idea does not merely correspond to an object; it expresses its cause and productive relations.

pp. 92–93

Form and content co-generate

Reflection and expression intertwine so method and object, means and end, validate one another within the same chain.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 78–79

    The Treatise is read as the difficulty of how method begins, not as a rulebook.

  2. pp. 82–83

    Method cannot wait infinitely for another method's proof; it must validate itself within thought.

  3. pp. 84–85

    The form of a true idea is reflective: an idea can become an idea of an idea.

  4. pp. 87–88

    Reflection does not abandon the object; it makes the genetic relation of knowing perceptible.

  5. pp. 89–90

    The content of a true idea is expressive: it expresses its cause and productive relations.

  6. pp. 92–93

    Form and content, means and end, method and object validate one another in one genetic chain.

03
pp. 94–140 · 第三章 规定和差异:以‘如何规定圆’为例的方法比较

How six methods of definition compete

A good definition does not merely list properties of a finished object; it carries the object's movement of genesis. Comparing methods means comparing the differences they produce.

How to define a circle becomes a shared experimental field. Analytic, constructive, negative, synthetic, practical, and paradoxical routes connect respectively with Descartes, Kant, Hegel, Aristotle, Hume, and Deleuze. Rather than choosing a static winner, Qin observes how each definition arranges conditions, facts, levels, and genesis.

pp. 95–96

Analytic definition

Properties are extracted from a finished object, often leaving genesis outside the definition.

pp. 97–106

Constructive definition

Kantian construction brings conditions of constructibility into the object, while leaving the genesis of those conditions to be asked.

pp. 107–113

Negative definition

Hegel advances definition through contradiction, allowing Qin to highlight Deleuze's reservations about producing difference through negation.

pp. 114–118

Synthetic definition

Aristotelian genus, species, and induction organize empirical material while preselecting which differences can appear.

pp. 119–124

Practical definition

Hume returns relations to habit, use, and experiential association, making definition a practical effect.

pp. 125–134

Paradoxical definition

The Deleuze-Spinoza route defines the circle through the movement that produces it, carrying cause within definition.

pp. 135–140

Deleuzian definition

Definition crosses levels of form and content, principle and fact, method and product; comparison itself produces difference.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 94–95

    How a circle is defined establishes a shared experiment for comparing methods.

  2. pp. 97–98

    Kantian construction includes conditions of constructibility while leaving their genesis to be explained.

  3. pp. 107–108

    Hegelian negative definition advances through contradiction, highlighting Deleuze's reservations about negation.

  4. pp. 114–115

    Aristotelian synthesis and induction show how genus-species frameworks organize empirical material.

  5. pp. 119–120

    Hume's practical definition returns relation to habit, use, and experiential association.

  6. pp. 125–126

    The Deleuze-Spinoza route defines a circle through its producing movement, carrying cause within definition.

  7. pp. 135–136

    Paradoxical definition crosses levels of form/content, principle/fact, and method/product.

  8. pp. 139–140

    Comparison does not select a static correct answer; it reveals which differences a mode of definition produces.

04
pp. 144–176 · 第四章 概念和传统:从神学概念到《伦理学》界说

How expression rewrites transcendent theology as immanence

Concepts carry old problems but can transform them through relational recomposition. Once attribute, substance, and mode enter the mechanism of expression, cause no longer governs effects from outside the world.

Qin enters the definitions of Spinoza's Ethics through conceptual history. Attribute and divine names, substance-mode, and one-many are rearranged; univocity removes hierarchy, and expression converts the question of how God enters the world into how the movement of substance is immanent to the world's movement.

pp. 146–155

Attribute and divine names

Attribute inherits theological naming while changing hierarchical relations among God, human beings, and being through univocity.

pp. 156–165

Substance-mode and one-many

A mode is not an inferior copy outside substance but a determinate expression of its power.

pp. 166–173

Expression and tradition

Expression inherits theological vocabulary while transforming its problem so cause and effect remain on one plane of immanence.

pp. 174–176

Recasting the problem

The issue is no longer how substance moves into the world but how its movement occurs only within the movement of attributes and modes.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 144–145

    Conceptual history rather than isolated word meaning opens the definitions of Spinoza's Ethics.

  2. pp. 146–147

    Attribute connects with the theological tradition of divine names, showing that concepts carry old problems.

  3. pp. 152–153

    Univocity changes the hierarchical distribution among God, human beings, and being.

  4. pp. 156–157

    Substance and mode are not an external one and many but two poles within expression.

  5. pp. 162–163

    A mode is not an inferior copy outside substance but a determinate expression of its power.

  6. pp. 166–167

    Expression inherits and transforms theological tradition, making immanence the central problem.

  7. pp. 175–176

    The conclusion recasts God entering the world as a movement in which cause remains immanent to effect.

05
pp. 177–217 · 第五章 文本和改造:从神的证明到内在的权能

Interpreting Spinoza must itself be immanent

Textual rearrangement avoids arbitrary rewriting only when constrained by conceptual relations and transformation of problems. The way expression is interpreted must itself become expressive.

The chapter compares Spinoza's order of proof with Deleuze's rearrangement, moving from immanent cause to the force and capacity of modes. The interpreter does not stand outside the object: when method enters conceptual movement, interpretation and interpreted object form an isomorphic circuit.

pp. 178–185

Immanent cause

Cause does not leave its effect, and the effect does not detach from the cause it expresses.

pp. 186–211

The power of modes

An individual is not merely a passive effect; capacity is measured through relations of affecting and being affected, acting and undergoing.

pp. 212–215

Interpretation and entwinement

The interpreter's procedure enters the interpreted concept rather than pronouncing conclusions from outside the text.

pp. 216–217

Isomorphism of method and object

The method of interpreting expression becomes expressive, forming an immanent method-object circuit.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 177–178

    Spinoza's order of proof and Deleuze's rearrangement show how interpretation transforms a text.

  2. pp. 181–182

    An immanent cause does not leave its effect, nor does the effect detach from the cause it expresses.

  3. pp. 186–187

    The power of modes turns the individual from passive effect into a composition of intensities with capacities for action.

  4. pp. 194–195

    Power as capacity is not domination but what a being can do and undergo.

  5. pp. 204–205

    Textual rearrangement is not arbitrary rewriting; conceptual relations and transformed problems constrain it.

  6. pp. 212–213

    Interpretation and entwinement place the interpreter's procedure within the movement of the interpreted concept.

  7. pp. 216–217

    The interpretation of expression becomes expressive itself, forming an isomorphic circuit of method and object.

06
pp. 218–286 · 第六章 差异的概念:差分化及其变体

How differentiation varies through becoming, event, and sense

Differentiation is the double process from virtual problem-structure to actual solutions. Becoming, event, and sense are not four loose vocabularies but variants of one methodological machine at different levels.

The chapter begins with differential relations and singularities in the double process of différentiation/différenciation, then develops it as becoming, where identity boundaries destabilize together; event, which no accident exhausts; and sense, expressed by a proposition but irreducible to denotation. Nonsense is the paradoxical excess that makes heterogeneous series communicate.

pp. 218–235

Differentiation as method

Differential relations and singularities are determined within a virtual problem and actualized in qualities and parts.

pp. 236–247

Differentiation as becoming

Becoming is not a transition from completed state A to B but a middle movement destabilizing the A/B boundary together.

pp. 248–261

Differentiation as event

A bodily state of affairs actualizes but does not exhaust an event; counter-actualization lets the performer take up the event without coinciding with resentment toward the accident.

pp. 262–277

Differentiation as sense

Sense is what a proposition expresses while differing from denotation, manifestation, and signification.

pp. 278–286

Nonsense and the paradoxical element

Nonsense is not nothingness but an excessive position circulating through series and enabling heterogeneous terms to communicate.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 218–219

    Differentiation is proposed as a double process from virtual problem-structure to actual solutions.

  2. pp. 226–227

    Calculus and embryology supply models, but a philosophical concept is not a transplanted scientific term.

  3. pp. 236–237

    Becoming is not transition between completed states but a middle movement destabilizing identity on both sides.

  4. pp. 248–249

    Event differs from state of affairs: no bodily actualization exhausts the event.

  5. pp. 255–256

    The actor-role model presents counter-actualization: taking up an event without coinciding with personal resentment toward the accident.

  6. pp. 262–263

    Sense is what a proposition expresses but is not denotation, manifestation, or signification.

  7. pp. 278–279

    Nonsense is not absence but an excessive term that makes heterogeneous series communicate and produce sense.

  8. pp. 285–286

    Differentiation, becoming, event, and sense are variants of one method at different levels.

07
pp. 290–329 · 第七章 爱丽丝和意义的冒险

How Alice turns method into narrative apparatus

Lewis Carroll's names, twins, squares and circles, and Snark are not illustrations of concepts. They make pure becoming, double series, infinite regress, and the empty-place object operate within language and narrative.

The chapter moves from Tweedledum and Tweedledee's exchange of identities into pure becoming, tests naming through the regress of a song's title, exposes the power to define through Humpty Dumpty's square-circle problem, and makes the Snark, the purloined letter, handkerchief, and crown circulate as empty-place objects between series. It ends with learning: problems begin in encounters with singular signs.

pp. 290–302

Twins: pure becoming and double series

Names and bodies exchange, preventing identity from serving as the stable origin of change.

pp. 303–308

Infinite regress and the song's name

The name of the song and what the name is called send linguistic levels into regress, making the naming relation itself an object.

pp. 309–317

The square circle and Humpty Dumpty

The question of who may define a word connects paradoxical definition, power, and the production of sense.

pp. 318–325

Nonsense and hunting the Snark

Hunting an object that cannot be fixed turns empty place and serial movement into narrative mechanisms.

pp. 326–329

Empty-place object and learning

The empty-place object migrates between series, and encounter with a singular sign opens a problem rather than filling it from an answer.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 290–291

    The twins test identity and pure becoming through exchanges of name and body.

  2. pp. 297–298

    Two series are not static parallels; a paradoxical element circulating between them sets both in motion.

  3. pp. 303–304

    The name of the song and what the name is called stage an endless regress of linguistic levels.

  4. pp. 309–310

    Humpty Dumpty's power to name links paradoxical definition to the production of sense.

  5. pp. 314–315

    The square-circle problem shows paradox not merely violating logic but exposing conditions of definition.

  6. pp. 318–319

    The hunting of the Snark turns objectlessness, empty place, and serial movement into a narrative apparatus.

  7. pp. 326–327

    The Snark, purloined letter, handkerchief, and crown are juxtaposed as empty-place objects circulating between series.

  8. p. 329

    A problem opens through encounter with a singular sign rather than being backfilled from an answer.

08
pp. 330–374 · 第八章 方法和生命:生命哲学视野下的差分化

Creation must submit to an evaluation of life

Differentiation, intuition, and dramatization make concept creation rigorous, yet creation is not good by itself. It must be evaluated by whether relations increase capacities to feel, think, and act.

Intuition is not inward inspiration but a procedure for distinguishing tendencies in kind and establishing true problems. Dramatization supplies concepts with genetic scenes by asking who, when, where, and through which forces. Qin then introduces the danger of creation, rejects the equation of novelty with value, and concludes pedagogically: teaching arranges encounters rather than copies answers.

pp. 331–346

Differentiation and intuitive thought

Bergsonian intuition establishes true problems along tendencies and differences in kind, returning differentiation to processes of life.

pp. 347–353

Problematization and dramatization

Who, how, when, where, and through which forces recast static essence as genetic conditions.

pp. 354–361

The danger of creation

Creation can open relations and can produce control or destruction; formal novelty is not proof of value.

pp. 362–369

Good, bad, and capacities of life

Evaluation turns to whether relations increase capacities for action, feeling, and thought.

pp. 370–374

Deleuze as educator

Teaching arranges encounters, problems, and signs so learners generate relations rather than copy completed knowledge.

EXACT PRINT LOCATORS

  1. pp. 330–331

    A philosophy-of-life perspective returns differentiation to Bergsonian intuition and the construction of true problems.

  2. pp. 339–340

    Intuition is not inward feeling but a rigorous division of differences, tendencies, and problem conditions.

  3. pp. 347–348

    Dramatization asks who, when, where, and through which force, giving the concept a genetic scene.

  4. pp. 354–355

    Philosophy as concept creation also brings risk; creation itself cannot simply be equated with the good.

  5. pp. 362–363

    Evaluation turns to whether a relation increases capacities to act, feel, and think.

  6. pp. 370–371

    Teaching should arrange encounters rather than transmit copies.

  7. p. 374

    The book locates methodological value in fostering life's differentiation rather than building a closed system.

03

WORKING CONCEPTS

18 searchable, operational concepts

01 · pp. 6–12, 212–217entwinement

Entwinement

Concepts, traditions, textual levels, and interpretive acts enter one another without merging into identity.

OPERATION
Identify each term, the direction of entry, and where difference is retained.
BOUNDARY
Not a vague network in which everything relates, nor evidence-free association.
02 · pp. 17–77dogmatic image of thought

Dogmatic image of thought

A set of postulates that makes thought appear natural, well-intentioned, identical, and capable of recognizing truth.

OPERATION
Identify the subject, object, correct direction, and form of failure presumed by an analysis.
BOUNDARY
Everyday recognition has uses; the problem is smuggling it in as the general model of thought.
03 · pp. 17–20innate thought

Innate thought

The capacity and right direction of thought are assigned to the subject in advance.

OPERATION
Ask through which encounter, training, and institutional relation a subject is forced to think.
BOUNDARY
Not a denial that people think, but a refusal to naturalize its conditions of genesis.
04 · pp. 21–25common sense / good sense

Common sense / good sense

Common sense coordinates faculties around one object; good sense orders a shared direction from indetermination to determination.

OPERATION
Record separately whether perception, memory, imagination, and action actually converge on one object.
BOUNDARY
Social consensus and moral conscience are not identical to these technical senses.
05 · pp. 26–38recognition / reconnaissance

Recognition

The operation that subordinates different sensations, memories, and imaginings to the same object.

OPERATION
Check whether an unrecognizable detail changes viewing or action.
BOUNDARY
Recognition is one practical capacity but not a sufficient model of creative thought.
06 · pp. 32–45representation / représentation

Representation

Difference is arranged through identity, resemblance, analogy, and opposition into forms governable by existing concepts.

OPERATION
Specify which representational mechanism recuperates each difference.
BOUNDARY
An image having representational content does not mean analysis must be governed by representation.
07 · pp. 53–64true and false problems

True / false problem

A true problem produces and distributes conditions of solution; a false problem often comes from mixed divisions or a ready answer projected backward.

OPERATION
State which possible solutions the problem redistributes before evaluating answers.
BOUNDARY
Difficulty, an open ending, or missing information does not by itself make a problem true.
08 · pp. 65–77, 329learning and signs

Learning and signs

Learning is encounter with a sign that must be interpreted but cannot be immediately recognized, pushing faculties into discordant exercise.

OPERATION
Record the sign, failure of recognition, new task of each faculty, and generated skill.
BOUNDARY
A sign is not a hidden message, and learning is not copying the correct answer.
09 · pp. 78–93true idea / idea vera

True idea

An idea reflective in form and expressive of its object's productive cause in content.

OPERATION
Make the analytic method show how it holds within relations of the material.
BOUNDARY
Not merely a correct judgment corresponding to an object.
10 · pp. 89–93, 166–176expression

Expression

Cause, attribute, mode, and idea manifest themselves in an immanent relation rather than through an external subject representing an object.

OPERATION
Analyse how image, sound, and body act on one another before discussing subjective viewing.
BOUNDARY
Not a general term for self-expression, message transmission, or symbolism.
11 · pp. 146–165univocity of being

Univocity of being

Being is said in one sense of different beings while differences of intensity and mode remain.

OPERATION
Check whether human, object, and image operations share one plane while retaining their differences.
BOUNDARY
Not the claim that all beings are identical or equal in value.
12 · pp. 174–182immanent cause / causa immanens

Immanent cause

Cause does not leave its effect, and the effect does not stand outside its cause.

OPERATION
Map how cause continues to act within the ongoing movement of its effect.
BOUNDARY
Not the abolition of causality or the reduction of everything to a closed system.
13 · pp. 186–205power / puissance

Power / capacity

A being's relational capacity to affect and be affected, to act and undergo.

OPERATION
Compare capacities for action, feeling, and connection gained or lost across a scene.
BOUNDARY
Not domination, status advantage, victory, or intensity of violence.
14 · pp. 218–235différentiation / différenciation

Differentiation / differenciation

The first determines differential relations and singularities in a virtual problem; the second actualizes them in qualities and parts.

OPERATION
Record virtual relation, singularity, actualizing operation, and actual result in separate fields.
BOUNDARY
Not generic change, and the two French processes must not be collapsed into one undifferentiated synonym.
15 · pp. 236–247, 290–302becoming / devenir

Becoming

A middle movement not bounded by completed identities A and B, destabilizing both sides together.

OPERATION
Find zones of proximity, mutual transformation, and intensities not attributable to one side alone.
BOUNDARY
Not imitation, costume change, a growth arc, or movement from A into a completed B.
16 · pp. 248–261event / Aion

Event / Aion

The event as expressed is not exhausted by one bodily state of affairs; Aion divides it simultaneously toward what has passed and what is to come.

OPERATION
Record both material accident and the unresolved relation still expressed audiovisually.
BOUNDARY
Philosophical distance does not erase harm, responsibility, or material consequence.
17 · pp. 262–286, 318–329sense / nonsense

Sense / nonsense

Sense is the event expressed by a proposition; nonsense is the paradoxical excess making heterogeneous series communicate.

OPERATION
Identify two series, the element circulating between them, and the rearrangement it produces.
BOUNDARY
Nonsense is not nothingness, gibberish, or lack of explanation.
18 · pp. 347–353dramatization

Dramatization

The dynamic conditions of a concept are asked through who, how, when, where, and by which forces.

OPERATION
Rewrite each abstraction as observable roles, times, spaces, and relations of force.
BOUNDARY
Not rhetorical dramatics or exaggerated conflict.
04

FOUR-LAYER RELATION CARDS

Separate author claims, primary entries, comparisons, and site tests

01
pp. 17–77

Thought begins in compulsion, not goodwill

BOOK ARGUMENT
The eight postulates conceal the encounter with the unrecognizable through which thought begins.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
The image of thought in chapter three of Difference and Repetition, and learning through signs in Proust and Signs.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
What Is Philosophy? treats opinion, rather than error alone, as thought's enemy.
SITE TEST
First locate a concrete audiovisual sign that breaks recognition, then test whether perception, memory, and thought change their uses.
02
pp. 78–93

Method must validate itself within its object

BOOK ARGUMENT
Reflective form and expressive content co-generate within the true idea.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
Spinoza's Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect and Deleuze's Expressionism in Philosophy: Spinoza.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
Film-form analysis cannot begin with a preset label; shot relations must show why a concept applies.
SITE TEST
Every conceptual case must provide at least one observable editing, audiovisual, or spatiotemporal relation and one counterexample.
03
pp. 94–140

A good definition carries genesis

BOOK ARGUMENT
Paradoxical definition includes the movement producing a circle within its definition.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
Genetic definition in Spinoza's Treatise and conditions of genesis in Difference and Repetition.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
A concept of montage should be defined through movement, interval, and transformation between shots rather than a list of stylistic attributes.
SITE TEST
Write the concept as input relation, transforming operation, and observable result, then state the boundary where it fails.
04
pp. 144–176

Expression places one and many on one immanent plane

BOOK ARGUMENT
The conceptual history of attribute, substance, and mode rewrites transcendent theology as immanent expression.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
Deleuze's Expressionism in Philosophy: Spinoza.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
Cinema 1 places images on an immanent plane of matter-light rather than treating them only as representations for consciousness.
SITE TEST
Analyse operative relations among images before subjective viewing; a POV shot does not automatically subordinate all images to a subject.
05
pp. 177–217

Capacity is measured relationally

BOOK ARGUMENT
The power of a mode is its capacity to affect and be affected, to act and undergo.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
Spinoza's Ethics and Deleuze's Spinoza: Practical Philosophy.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
Cinema of the body can express changing capacity through posture, fatigue, rhythm, touch, and spatial resistance.
SITE TEST
Record which possibilities of action, feeling, and connection are gained or lost in character-environment relations across the scene.
06
pp. 218–247

Differentiation connects virtual problem and actual form

BOOK ARGUMENT
Determination of virtual relations and actualization of actual differences form a double process.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
Chapters four and five of Difference and Repetition.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
The time-image in Cinema 2 directly images virtual past, actual present, and bifurcating future.
SITE TEST
Distinguish scrambled information from transformed temporal relation and identify the image-circuit making temporal layers coexist.
07
pp. 248–261

An event is not exhausted by its accident

BOOK ARGUMENT
A state of affairs actualizes but cannot exhaust an event; counter-actualization retains distance for reenactment and transformation.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
The event series of The Logic of Sense.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
Before and after in the time-image can remain suspended beyond action's result, keeping the event open to interpretation.
SITE TEST
List the bodily accident and the unresolved event expressed audiovisually; neither substitutes for the other.
08
pp. 330–374

Creation requires an evaluation of life

BOOK ARGUMENT
Concept creation carries danger, and its value depends on whether relations increase capacities of life.
RELATED PRIMARY ENTRY
What Is Philosophy? and Nietzsche and Philosophy.
CROSS-TEXT COMPARISON
New image technologies can open sensation and can close it into predictable stimulus.
SITE TEST
For every innovative form, ask which sensible, thinkable, and actionable relations it increases and whom or what it excludes.
05

FILM AND IMAGE MATRIX

Test book cases separately from site extensions

Paired male and female statues in the garden in Last Year at Marienbad
Conflicting accounts of one statue make memory and viewpoint rewrite one another. Atlas scene-evidence ledger
01 · SITE EXTENSION

Last Year at Marienbad

L’Année dernière à Marienbad · Alain Resnais · 1961

Site extension: hotel space, repeated narration, and conflicting memories test whether one version can exhaust an event.

02 · SITE EXTENSION

Vertigo

Vertigo · Alfred Hitchcock · 1958

Site extension: Scottie's remaking of Judy turns recognition and representation's suppression of difference into a visible operation.

The singer lies on the Club Silencio stage while the song continues in Mulholland Drive
Club Silencio separates voice, performing body, mechanical playback, and spectator affect. Atlas scene-evidence ledger
03 · SITE EXTENSION

Mulholland Drive

Mulholland Drive · David Lynch · 2001

Site extension: the blue box, exchanged names, and Club Silencio test empty-place object, nonsense, and audiovisual separation together.

04 · SITE EXTENSION

Céline and Julie Go Boating

Céline et Julie vont en bateau · Jacques Rivette · 1974

Site extension: sweets, the house, and repeated performance turn Alice-like learning through signs into a cinematic apparatus.

05 · SITE EXTENSION

Orpheus

Orphée · Jean Cocteau · 1950

Site extension: mirror passages, reversed movement, and radio codes test how two worlds express themselves through one interface.

06 · SITE EXTENSION

Stalker

Сталкер · Andrei Tarkovsky · 1979

Site extension: detours through the Zone, the Room, and desire disable action-goals and force the characters to reformulate the problem.

07 · SITE EXTENSION

La Jetée

La Jetée · Chris Marker · 1962

Site extension: stills, sound, and memory circuits test when repeated images produce different temporal relations.

08 · SITE EXTENSION

Je t’aime, je t’aime

Je t’aime, je t’aime · Alain Resnais · 1968

Site extension: a failed time experiment releases fragments of the past from linear action and makes them return according to a problem-structure.

09 · SITE EXTENSION

Meshes of the Afternoon

Meshes of the Afternoon · Maya Deren & Alexander Hammid · 1943

Site extension: door, key, flower, and knife exchange places in a loop, making props differential operators migrating between series.

10 · SITE EXTENSION

The Exterminating Angel

El ángel exterminador · Luis Buñuel · 1962

Site extension: an invisible prohibition and repeated failures to leave shift the problem from visible obstacle to relational configuration.

11 · SITE EXTENSION

Persona

Persona · Ingmar Bergman · 1966

Site extension: superimposed faces, audiovisual fissures, and film rupture test how identity and image-material destabilize together.

12 · SITE EXTENSION

Inland Empire

Inland Empire · David Lynch · 2006

Site extension: leaking roles, nested scenes, and rabbit passages test when heterogeneous series produce communication.

13 · SITE EXTENSION

Sans Soleil

Sans Soleil · Chris Marker · 1983

Site extension: epistolary voice-over, travel images, and Zone processing test how images express memory rather than represent a past object.

A boy lowers his head before a timber wall while an oval mirror above contains another group of interior figures
The present body and mirrored figures share a space without reducing to one viewing position. Atlas scene-evidence ledger
14 · SITE EXTENSION

Mirror

Зеркало · Andrei Tarkovsky · 1975

Site extension: a mirror compresses a present body and another temporal position into one frame, testing whether actual and virtual exchange reciprocally.

06

OUTWARD PERSPECTIVES

Extend the book without back-projecting later problems into it

01

Algorithmic recognition and synthetic images

QUESTION
When a classifier decides what this is in advance, which differences can still force system or viewer to alter judgment?
EXTENSION
Extend the eight postulates into facial recognition, recommender labels, generative models, and automated moderation.
TENSION
Qin studies philosophical method and does not predict machine learning; algorithmic comparison is a later site experiment.
TEST
Record training category, unrecognized item, human override, affected subject, and whether feedback changes the model.
02

Pedagogy of encounter and assessment

QUESTION
Does a course transmit recognizable answers or arrange encounters through which learners generate problems?
EXTENSION
Turn Deleuze as educator into tasks of observation, rewriting, comparison, and counterexample in the film classroom.
TENSION
Forcing thought is not coercing students; pedagogy must preserve agency, opt-out, and accessibility.
TEST
Compare problem-structures before and after the course rather than only accuracy of term recall.
03

Translation, double terms, and conceptual difference

QUESTION
Does one Chinese equivalent flatten two distinct processes in the source language?
EXTENSION
Use différentiation/différenciation as a model for Chinese-French-English records of process, page, and use.
TENSION
Etymological difference is not automatic proof of conceptual correctness; syntax, argument, and operation remain decisive.
TEST
For each disputed term, record original, context, process, and the gains and losses of translation.
04

Archive, provenance, and interpretive circuits

QUESTION
When an image is re-edited, annotated, and recommended, how does interpretation enter the object and alter its future uses?
EXTENSION
Extend interpretation and entwinement into digital archives, metadata, subtitles, and platform circulation.
TENSION
Interpretation entering its object does not erase distinctions of provenance, edition, and rightsholder.
TEST
Build a traceable chain across original, digitization, edit, annotation, publication, and reuse.
05

Evaluation of life, ecology, and infrastructure

QUESTION
Whose capacity does an image innovation increase, and onto which bodies, workers, and environments does it displace cost?
EXTENSION
Extend evaluation of life from character ethics to computation, energy, devices, labour, and accessibility.
TENSION
Capacity is not abstract vitality; an increase here may coincide with diminished capacity elsewhere.
TEST
List beneficiaries, harmed parties, material inputs, reversibility, and long-term relational change separately.
07

FIVE-STEP READING ROUTE

Each step produces a checkable reading output

  1. 01
    pp. 17–77

    Build the negative measure first

    Annotate one sequence for the eight postulates: innate thought, common sense, recognition, representation, error, proposition, problem, and knowledge.

  2. 02
    pp. 78–140

    Build a genetic definition

    Write input, transformation, and result for one shot relation, then compare six modes of definition: analytic, constructive, negative, synthetic, practical, and paradoxical.

  3. 03
    pp. 144–217

    Enter the Spinozist hinge

    Map attribute, substance, mode, expression, immanent cause, and capacity, then test the map through changing capacities across a scene.

  4. 04
    pp. 218–329

    Read differentiation four times

    Read one sequence through virtual/actual, becoming, event/state of affairs, and sense/nonsense.

  5. 05
    pp. 330–374

    Conclude through an evaluation of life

    For one formal innovation, state the capacities to feel, think, act, and participate that it increases and diminishes.

08

EDITIONS, SOURCES, AND RIGHTS

Return from the guide to editions, catalogues, and research

Copyright remains with China Federation of Literary and Art Circles Publishing House, Qin Lanjun, and relevant rightsholders. This page publishes original paraphrase, narrow print locators, cross-textual comparison, and editorial tests only; no source PDF, OCR, scanned cover, copyright page, contents image, or continuous translation enters the public site.

Image boundary: covers identify editions; film images are single, low-resolution frames from the atlas evidence ledger, each retaining its carrier and timecode. No open licence is asserted for these third-party images, and original-image downloads are not offered.

CATALOGUE RECORD

OCLC WorldCat record

Qin Lanjun, The Poetics of Intertwinement: Study on Deleuze's Way of Thinking, China Federation of Literary and Art Circles Publishing House, first edition and printing, March 2017, ISBN 9787519024956, OCLC 1273522851. The parallel English title is bibliographic metadata, not evidence of a published translation.

Edition, language, and holdings verification; no authorized full-text open access or formal translation located.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

Difference and Repetition

Related primary entry for the image of thought, problems, difference, and the double process of differentiation.

Published-edition entry at Columbia University Press.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

The Logic of Sense

Related primary text for becoming, event, Aion, sense/nonsense, and the Alice series.

Published-edition entry at Columbia University Press.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

What Is Philosophy?

Related primary entry for concept creation, plane of immanence, and art's preservation of sensation.

Published-edition entry at Columbia University Press.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

Cinema 1: The Movement-Image

Cross-textual entry for movement-image, perception/affection/action, and the sensory-motor schema.

Published-edition entry at the University of Minnesota Press.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

Cinema 2: The Time-Image

Cross-textual entry for pure optical and sound situations, crystal, bifurcating time, body, and thought.

Published-edition entry at the University of Minnesota Press.
RELATED PRIMARY TEXT

A Thousand Plateaus

Extended primary reading for becoming, assemblage, deterritorialization, and plane of immanence.

Published-edition entry at the University of Minnesota Press.